• Hungarian forint
  • Budapest
  • Police news
  • HelloMagyar
Between the United States of Austria and Greater RomaniaBetween the United States of Austria and Greater RomaniaBetween the United States of Austria and Greater RomaniaBetween the United States of Austria and Greater Romania
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Society
  • Sport
  • Culture
  • Special Hungary
  • News To Go
  • World
  • Contact Us
  • About us
  • About us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
✕
Important
  • Hungary’s first ever Islamic cemetery to be built near Budapest

  • Brutal fuel price hike comes from January in Hungary

Support us
Alpár Kató Alpár Kató · 04/01/2019
· Society

Between the United States of Austria and Greater Romania

treaty trianon

Photo: www.americanhungarianfederation.org/

In 2018 it was the 100th anniversary of Transylvania becoming part of the entity today called Great Romania.

As a Romanian and Transylvanian, I have no reason for a joyful celebration, on the contrary, I am sad. If I had lived in 1918 and anticipated the incompetence, impatience and corruption of the Bucharest regimes, for next moments, I would have been indecisive to choose between a Romanian, a Balkan-type, incompetent and corrupt government and a Nationalistic Hungary.

Because what could Bucharest offer to the Romanians in Transylvania beyond the dominance of the Romanian language? Did we choose the best alternative for Transylvania in 1918? What would Transylvania look like if the First World War did not have happened? How would we explain Budapest’s desire for the magyarization of non-Hungarian ethnic groups?

Looking back into the past, in order to find the right answer, we must take into account one of the consequences of the French Revolution of 1789, namely the emergence of nationalism and the idea of a nation-based state. The Hungarians, through the French Revolution, entered the 19th century in the spell of political thinking, embodying the concept of national unity. Accordingly, Hungary has sought to become a nation-state like other European countries.

However, this effort was not easy, as, at the beginning of the 19th century, less than forty percent of the total population of Hungary and Transylvania spoke Hungarian. German philosopher, Johann Gottfried Herder predicted that the Hungarian language would disappear within a few centuries due to the low birth rate of the Hungarian population. To remedy this situation, the Hungarian governments, at the time of dualism, started a policy of magyarization that culminated before the First World War. In the following, I will propose a scenario, in other words, an “alternative history” of how Transylvania’s fate could have been if the assassination of Archduke Francis Ferdinand, the Austrian-Hungarian throne, does not happen. The Crown Prince was a rather interesting and mysterious personality. In the years when he was expected to take over the leadership of the Austro-Hungarian Monarchy, he cherished reform plans that would become viable in the 20th century.

In this context, the idea and plan of the United States of Great Austria were born. The detailed plan prepared by a group of scientists belonging to the Ferenc Ferdinand crown prince environment was worked out by the Romanian Aurel Popovici in 1906, and later he wrote a book United States of Austria.

Archduke Franz Ferdinand knew the situation of the Romanians and the other minorities, and he intended to divide the empire with the centre of Vienna into fifteen, ethnically and linguistically unified semi-autonomous states, thus preserving the empire as well as solving the problems of the nationalities. What would it have meant for the Romanians in Transylvania if the Prince of the Throne survived the assassination and could implement his plan?

This would have been a chance to preserve the Romanian identity in Transylvania without breaking away from Western civilisation. Having a capital in Bucharest is different than in Vienna.

Likewise, it would have meant that our Transylvanian culture and civilisation would remain untouched, along with the Hungarian and German minorities and their culture. Hungarians and Germans have established a cultural relationship between the West and us through the centuries. From the point of tourism, Transylvania would have created the best and most attractive tourist attractions in Eastern Europe. Also, we would have had the opportunity to stay away from most criminals, incompetent and corrupt governments in Bucharest.

Likewise, we would not have had any connections with the Balkan-culture of the Old Romanian Kingdom. The Transylvanian Romanians expressed their support for reunification with the Kingdom of Romania. But they did not know what was expected of them. It would have been much better if Romanian Transylvanian politicians, who knew corruption and the mentality of the Romanian Kingdom, demanded autonomy for Transylvania under strict conditions. And what can we do today? Let’s rebuild Transylvania’s cultural memory by studying local history and cultural history, restoring the many historic monuments left to collapse, love and appreciate the Hungarians and Germans as they have remained among us, but be proud of being Transylvanians.

You can read this manifesto in Hungarian HERE.

The author Cornel Unc is a Baptist pastor in Windsor, Canada.

Button

Source: by Cornel Unc

If you would like to support the work of the Daily News Hungary staff and independent journalism,
please make a donation here
Austria History Romania Transylvania
Share

Hot news

  • What happened today in Hungary? – 8 December, 2023

  • Final decision: euro hundred millions to come to Hungary in 2024

  • PM Orbán for deepening Hungarian-Serbian friendship – UPDATED

  • Authority: Hungary must change asset declaration system

  • Romania will help Hungary’s battery revolution with energy, electricity?

  • Survey: Hungarians against importing this Ukrainian product

3 Comments

  1. Edward says:
    04/01/2019 at 18:42

    Would have been better if Transylvania were independent, rather than given to backward thinking goat breeders.

  2. alex says:
    04/01/2019 at 19:38

    As Romanian from Transylvania i also embrace some ideas of mister Cornel Unc. But trying to imagine now alternative realities and possibilities is a waste of time and just a sweet way of dreaming for the best. Let’s not forget that the incapability of the Hungarian members of the Parliament to communicate with the Romanian members and the eager of those to ridicule the minorities representatives , led to the refusal of further negotiations between the two parts in 1918. Of course that Iuliu Maniu and Vaida Voevod the leaders of the Romanians from Transylvania hoped that in a national state their allegations would be better listened to but surprise , the leaders from Bucharest were as retarded as the ones from Budapest before the war. Now we can only unite and make our own future in a decentralized state in our autonomous region of Transylvania/Erdely/Siebenburgen. This is still a dream of ours for the moment but it can become reality soon. In 100 years they tried to erase our 1000 years of multicultural traditions with a bloody 100 years centralized so called Romanian unity. In 100 years the Germans who survived for 800 years in Siebenburgen are almost gone . All we can do is coexist in peace and try to keep our Transylvanian spirit intact. Have a good day!

  3. Transylvania says:
    17/04/2019 at 19:26

    HUNGARY IS MORE CORRUPT THAN ROMANIA !!!
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_Perceptions_Index

    This is retarded hungarian propaganda and lies… Hungary is more corrupt than Romania and the minimum salary is the same in both countries (300 euro).. but you talk as if Hungary is like Switzerland and Romania like Syria… dirty asiatic hun-gypsie nomads.. Go back to your true homeland India from where you invaded Europe 1100 years ago to steal and rape. And don’t forget your gypsie dictator Orban ! Ria ria India !

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

SUPPORT US
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

Must read

Subscribe to our newsletter

Sign up to receive daily updates, news & stories about Hungary!

Select your location below or enter your country so we can deliver our morning newsletters to you in time.

Thank you!

You have successfully joined our subscriber list.

.

Contact us

About us

Copyright rules

Privacy policy

Advertise with us

© 2023 DailyNewsHungary. All rights reserved! | Server and development by Svigelj Levente E.V
What happened today in Hungary? – 8 December, 2023

What happened today in Hungary? – 8 December, 2023

Read More
Final decision: euro hundred millions to come to Hungary in 2024

Final decision: euro hundred millions to come to Hungary in 2024

Read More
PM Orbán for deepening Hungarian-Serbian friendship – UPDATED

PM Orbán for deepening Hungarian-Serbian friendship – UPDATED

Read More
Authority: Hungary must change asset declaration system

Authority: Hungary must change asset declaration system

Read More
Romania will help Hungary’s battery revolution with energy, electricity?

Romania will help Hungary’s battery revolution with energy, electricity?

Read More
Survey: Hungarians against importing this Ukrainian product

Survey: Hungarians against importing this Ukrainian product

Read More
Orbán’s system conquered the Hungarian stock exchange!

Orbán’s system conquered the Hungarian stock exchange!

Read More
<strong> Orbán: Ukraine is corrupt, Hungary will not be mixed nation </strong>

Orbán: Ukraine is corrupt, Hungary will not be mixed nation

Read More
Another kick into Schengen: border control prolonged at this Hungarian border

Another kick into Schengen: border control prolonged at this Hungarian border

Read More
Hungary completes ‘largest ever’ economic development scheme in Africa

Hungary completes ‘largest ever’ economic development scheme in Africa

Read More
  • 0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
Have you read it?