Explanation after Hungary’s veto: aid to Ukraine is not fair – UPDATE
Certain European Union countries’ attempt to link the approval of Hungary’s recovery fund to “completely unrelated” issues such as the global minimum corporate tax or a 18 billion euro loan taken out to aid Ukraine is “not fair” and “would create a dangerous precedent”, Finance Minister Mihály Varga said in Brussels on Tuesday.
Varga told a press conference after a meeting of EU finance and economy ministers (ECOFIN) that the European Commission’s recent positive assessment of Hungary’s recovery plan “after a year and a half” was a “significant step forward”. All member states support the plan’s content, and so it could be officially approved before the end of the year, he said.
At the same time, Varga regretted that the EC has maintained its proposal to suspend disbursement of funds for three operative programmes, despite the government’s fulfillment of 17 requirements until the November deadline.
Since this is the first time the rule of law conditionality is being used, several member states have said that the EC “should remain fair, objective and proportionate” and “base its standpoint on facts”, he said.
“Several member states have called for an objective evaluation, considering Hungary’s steps taken after November 19th; France and Germany, among others, think the Commission’s evaluation is somewhat disproportionate,”
Varga said. He expressed hope that the EC would conclude the procedure with a more “objective” assessment.
Regarding plans that EU member states would take out a joint loan of 18 billion euros to aid Ukraine, Varga said Hungary will not give its consent to that plan. “We have had bad experiences with joint loans – the one taken out during the coronavirus pandemic did not help Hungary to access the resources,” he said.
Hungary is ready to help Ukraine further but will only disburse its own resources on the basis of a bilateral agreement with concrete goals set in advance, he said, adding that Hungary already had the resources for that aid in its central budget at hand.
Meanwhile, Hungary has received over 1 million Ukrainian refugees and spent 31 billion forints (EUR 75.3m) on support for the country, he said.
Touching on the issue of the global minimum corporate tax, Varga noted that at 9 percent, Hungary’s tax rate was one of the lowest. The international attempt to introduce a global minimum tax would raise that to 15 percent, he said. Such a step would cost jobs and harm the country’s competitiveness, and so Hungary does not support it, he said.
Czech presidency – reaction
Commenting on the issue, the finance minister of the Czech Republic, holder of the current EU presidency, said Hungary’s recovery plan would be “handled as part of a package also including the 18 billion euro aid to Ukraine and the global minimum corporate tax”. “If there is no agreement on one issue, then there is none on the other ones, either,” Zbynek Stanjura told reporters after the ECOFIN meeting.
Approving the package will also depend on what sort of measures Hungary would implement in the interest of protecting the EU budget, he said, adding that the Czech presidency had asked the European Commission to prepare a fresh report evaluating “the progress” the Hungarian government had made in legislation in connection with the rule of law situation addressed by the commission.
“The Czech presidency is fully committed to finding a compromise. Once that is achieved, it will be a mere technicality to reach an agreement on the entire package by the end of the year,”
Stanjura said.
European Commission Vice-President Valdis Dombrovskis said Ukraine is fighting serious financing shortages, and is counting on the first instalment of the aid in January already. While they couldn’t reach an agreement at the meeting, the work will continue in the coming days, he said.
“Ukraine is at war, we can’t allow one member state to derail or delay the aid,” he said.
Read alsoBreaking news: Hungary blocks EU aid to Ukraine amid Russia war
Source: MTI
CORRECTION. We did not “receive” 1 million Ukrainian refugees. We took on 32’000. The rest went elsewhere:
https://data.unhcr.org/en/situations/ukraine
Also – a lot of countries believe we are funding our 9 percent corporate tax rate using our Europe beating 27 percent VAT rate. Which sort of distorts the balance in jurisdiction tax competition the Global Minimum Tax project is trying to address (“harmful tax competition”).
Lastly – unsurprising the EU is hesitant to believe our Politicians’ sincerity and effectiveness of the agreed 17 measures…
https://euobserver.com/rule-of-law/156510
Hungary’s attempt to link the approval of Hungary’s recovery fund to “completely unrelated” issues such as the global minimum corporate tax or a 18 billion euro loan taken out to aid Ukraine is “not fair” and “would create a dangerous precedent”, said Czech finance minister Zbyněk Stanjura.
You cannot come to the EU with your hand out and slap back the hand of Ukraine at the same moment. Stop shilling for PUTIN!!!!
This Orban Government – its DUG the deepening trenches of the cataclysmic widespread Economic & Financial SHAMBLES we in Hungary are living in and WORSENING,
BLAME – moving blame, when the Orban Government there KNOWN reputation – is that they are the provokers – the agitators – the architects who through the massive WRONGFULLNESS of the Political ideas & philosophy undertaken directed from Victor Orban – we as a country are literally “on our knees” in a survival pattern, if we can.
The bludgeoning of our name as a country, by this Orban Government, the destroyed relationships/friendships – the European Union “lost cause” nearing position of reconciliation or a future for Hungary – Appalling.
Hungary – our isolation – the abandonment we are FACED with as a country – Hungary – placed in this POSITION – through the Dictatorial style and practices of this Orban Government is HORRENDOUS.
We must not let the BLAME – the BULK of the BLAME – the DEEPENING of our Economic & Financial collapse, be THROWN at by this Hungarian Government, back onto BLAMING the European Union for our MESS.
Rule of Law and “other” violations of European Union Membership – by this Orban Government, proven in the Courts of the European Union “beyond reasonable doubt” – this Orban led Government simple expressed just ABUSED the purpose and reason – why there exists a Family of European Countries.
Dictatorships have a history – that when they are PRESURIZED – as is the Orban Government, little if no leverage to maneuver – get out of the MESS they have created, the handling of growing mounting CIVILIAN un-rest, in History, it is known these Government “Screw” their civilians harder and deeper in an attempt to hold POWER.
Hungary – deeper into a likened ABYSS we descend and WHAT are we GOING to Do in an Efford that must be of SOLIDARITY – to arrest and WIN back respectability from countries outside the boarders of Hungary?
Hungary – we can’t STAND alone – NEVER.