Consultation with the public is being launched over the fate of a memorial in Szabadság Square in downtown Budapest commemorating the German occupation of Budapest during the Second World War, Mayor Gergely Karácsony said on Facebook on Saturday.
The Budapest municipality and the government will decide jointly over the monument, Karácsony said, adding that the monument was “infinitely tasteless and infinitely deceitful”.
The memorial falsely suggests Hungary was blameless before the German occupation, ignoring the fact that anti-Jewish laws were enacted long before 1944, Karácsony said. The persecution of Jewish citizens began decades earlier, with the Hungarian state actively participating in the destruction of its Jewish population, he added.
“The claim that the Holocaust was solely a German crime against the Jews is a lie that must be erased from national memory,” he said, emphasising that the Hungarian state and its citizens played a significant role in the Holocaust.
The statue rightfully provoked widespread protest when it was erected 12 years ago, he said. After 12 years and political changes, its place on Szabadság Square must be reconsidered, he added.
He also noted that the memorial had inspired the Living Memorial project, where Hungarian citizens shared their family histories to counter the statue’s distorted narrative. Karácsony also warned that removing the statue could be exploited by the far right to fuel grievance politics.
If you missed it: Breakthrough: Demolition work at Budapest’s troubled Rákosrendező site could begin soon
Jew here, a child of Holocaust survivors. Half my family was wiped out by the Nazis.
My two cents: DON’T CARE.
My concern is that Budapest and Hungary be safe for me, my family, and my people. Statues do not determine the present-day nomos or circumstances that inform or affect that concern.
It’s pretty rich to be getting apoplectic about a statue while advocating “open borders” whereby thousands upon thousands of violent anti-Semites from the third world would flood Hungary’s streets.
Besides, have all the major problems of Budapest been satisfactorily resolved? I didn’t get that memo.
That’s not how open borders work, stop playing the victim.
Good point. But it seems the memorial should be removed if it is really not true to the history. Humans make horrible mistakes and usually learn something from it… that is somewhat good I guess… but historically allmost all wars were heroic in the eyes of the present leaders who most likely initiated the war. I’m curious how future Russia will describe the war against Ukraine in the coming history books.
Even though I feel sorry for what you suffered, but Steiner, same card played again.
No need to play the victim here. Live as everyone else, you are not better only due to your religion.
Simply you are not Hungarian, you dont like it, move forward to where you came from
People have voted, Hungarians don’t need to hear your nonsense and lies all the time.
“Tasteless and deceitful” is a great description of much of what Fidesz did. Perhaps we can now put back the 1056 memorial and the Nagy Imre memorial that they removed from Parliament. You know why those were removed don’t you?
It seems as though it might be better to leave it there and add information about context instead of destroying or hiding it. If the public decides to remove it, the public might do well to consider consulting with the Terror Háza, and then also with the Szoborpark. The Arrow Cross Party existed as much as some of what followed so at least a juxtaposition of some of their memorials at the Szoborpark might offer an opportunity to compare them somewhat more neutrally.
Remove it. A) it’s ugly and B) it is dishonest
Budapest is a beautiful city. We don’t need a reminder that it was once ruled by a gargoyle devoid of taste. In fact, the sooner he and his criminal enterprise is forgotten, the better for Hungary’s future.
I do agree that they should remove it… it’s appalling and horrifying that 70 years later Hungary, as a state, intends to shirk its responsibility, both symbolically and institutionally and socially, for this horrendous crime committed against the Jewish people. It’s unacceptable that a member of parliament TODAY has the audacity to have a statue of Horthy… it’s shameful and offensive… so… starting by removing that monument is a good beginning if the goal is to eliminate Hungarian Nazism.
What an eyesore
Out damn spot. Let it be gone. It should never have been erected, as evidenced by the immediate protest that followed. Steiner may not care but a great many Hungarian Jews very much do care about what the Arrow Cross inflicted on their forebears.
Londonsteve – Concur.
History never Lies.
Visual monuments in the case of the subject of this article, can be removed, but the history of them, the purpose of them – must NEVER be forgotten.