What is going on? Did half a million Hungarians get banned from Facebook?
A new study has exposed how many Hungarians are being restricted or banned on Facebook, with up to half a million users affected. The findings reveal that artificial intelligence is making most of the moderation decisions. However, most of the time, these decisions aren’t backed by a clear explanation. The situation leaves users and media outlets frustrated by ever-changing rules. The study also questions fairness and accountability while calling for clearer moderation policies.
Recent Facebook study
According to Index, a recent study commissioned by Hungary’s National Media and Infocommunications Authority (NMHH) has highlighted the opaque nature of Facebook’s content and account moderation policies, revealing that up to half a million Hungarians may have been restricted on the platform. Conducted by legal IT expert Zsolt Ződi, the research found that Facebook and other major platforms, such as YouTube, rely heavily on artificial intelligence to make millions of moderation decisions each month, often without human oversight. The study raises concerns about the transparency of these processes and the implications for users affected by automated restrictions. In addition, it also deals with potential improvements to moderation policies to enhance fairness and accountability.
Content removal and account restrictions
A recent study examining Facebook and YouTube’s moderation practices has revealed that their content removal and account restriction policies remain highly opaque, with users often left in the dark about enforcement decisions. The research highlights concerns over the dominance of artificial intelligence in moderation. It found that Facebook frequently enforces bans and shadow bans without clear explanations, leaving media companies and frequent users uncertain about ever-changing rules. With AI handling both restrictions and appeals, users are rarely given meaningful insights into the reasoning behind moderation decisions.
Widespread moderation issues affect Hungarians too
The recent study has revealed that Facebook’s moderation practices impact a significant number of Hungarian users, with 10-12% (around 500,000 people) reporting they have been banned or had their content removed. Alarmingly, half of these users have faced restrictions multiple times, and nearly a quarter have had their accounts suspended. Many affected users feel the explanations provided for these actions are inadequate, with 35-44% receiving no meaningful justification.
Media outlets’ struggle
The study also gathered insights from Hungarian media outlets, revealing that Facebook’s moderation policies create significant challenges. While some media organisations report occasional restrictions, others face repeated bans, with one outlet experiencing a full YouTube ban and multiple Facebook suspensions. A common concern among all media representatives is the lack of clarity in Facebook’s rules and the unpredictable nature of algorithm changes. The study, while not explicitly making recommendations, suggests improvements such as clearer rules, traceable updates, standardised reporting, better explanations for decisions, and increased human oversight in moderation.
Read also:
- Beyond politics: The most embarrassing TikTok moments of Hungarian politicians
- Hungarian news site banned in Russia
Featured image: depositphotos.com