LMP urges package to help forex borrowers

Daily News Hungary economy

The green opposition LMP has called on ruling Fidesz and the opposition Jobbik party to support its proposal aimed at helping troubled forex borrowers.

LMP spokesman Máté Kanász-Nagy told a press conference on Friday that under his party’s proposal, to be discussed at an extraordinary session of parliament, evictions of forex mortgage holders would be stopped. He added that some 60,000 families were facing evictions, while some 10,000 such procedures were already under way.

Meanwhile, commenting on press reports suggesting that heads of large state companies could be granted premiums of up to 80 percent of their annual income, the spokesman said that those “shameless” bonuses should be scrapped “unless railway or post office clerks, guards or delivery people are granted them too”.

Answering a question about another press report suggesting that staff at government agencies had doubled since 2010, Kanász-Nagy said that “Fidesz lied” when it had pledged a smaller bureaucracy.

On July, opposition Jobbik party has called on the government to revisit all decisions affecting FX loan-holders and to hold relevant discussions in parliament.

LMP backs Socialists’ call to hold special session of parliament

Daily News Hungary

Green opposition LMP has backed the Socialist Party’s call to hold a special session of parliament over the summer.

Last month, the Socialists called for parliament to hold an extraordinary session to amend Hungary’s higher education law after the European Commission stepped up an infringement procedure against Hungary over earlier amendments to the law.

LMP co-leader Ákos Hadházy expressed his support for the initiative at a press conference on Thursday but proposed that the agenda should also include passing legislation to suspend evictions in the cases of troubled forex loan holders as soon as possible. He said that some 3,000 borrowers ended up on the street last year while more than 10,000 eviction procedures had been launched so far this year. Hadházy added that bans on evictions should last until the situation of troubled borrowers is resolved.

He said his party’s motion to suspend evictions was backed by Jobbik and the Dialogue party, adding that there were reports that the co-ruling Christian Democrats were also prepared to support it.

István Ujhelyi, the Socialist Party’s deputy leader, told the same press conference that if parliament failed to act in connection with the higher education law, the matter would be referred to the Court of Justice of the European Union, which could leave Hungary with a hefty fine.

Ujhelyi said his party was proposing to hold the parliamentary session on August 21. He said the Socialists would also back discussing the situation of forex borrowers at the session.

The support of at least 40 lawmakers is required for a special session of parliament to be convened.

The ruling Fidesz-Christian Democrat alliance said it does not support convening a special session of parliament.

“[US financier] George Soros is having his local followers convene the Hungarian parliament to repeal ‘Lex CEU’ and place the Soros university above the law,” Fidesz said in a statement.

Jobbik calls on government reopen debate on FX loans

Daily News Hungary economy

Opposition Jobbik party has called on the government to revisit all decisions affecting FX loan-holders and to hold relevant discussions in parliament.

A law firm linked to László Trócsányi, the minister of Justice, represents the banks in lawsuits brought by borrowers, Jobbik lawmaker Dániel Z. Kárpát noted at a press conference on Tuesday.

“This is a lamentable and a shameful conflict of interest,” he said, adding that Fidesz’s impartiality on such matters was questionable.

The point of reference for converting FX loans into forints should be from the loan’s outset, he argued. Meanwhile, he called for eviction and non-payment procedures to be suspended.

It is wrong to doom borrowers who were largely blameless when it came to taking advantage of FX loans, the Jobbik politician said.

Answering a question about Jobbik MEP Béla Kovács, who failed to appear before the prosecutor earlier in June, Kárpát said ill health had prevented him for doing so.

Jobbik proposes renegotiation of forex loans

Daily News Hungary economy

Budapest, April 13 (MTI) – Opposition Jobbik is preparing to submit to parliament a proposal that would allow a renegotiation of foreign currency loans between banks and debtors, the party’s deputy leader said on Thursday.

The bill would enable banks and debtors to reach an agreement on extending the maturity of loans and rescheduling borrowers’ debts, Dániel Z Kárpát said.

He said a future law would establish that debts are to be settled in forints converted at the exchange rate that was valid on the loan disbursement date.

Z Kárpát said the debts borrowers were amassing due to the exchange rate cap were unjustified and proposed that those debts should be taken over by the banks.

Asked about Jobbik’s decision to back an appeal to the Constitutional Court over the recently amended law on higher education, Z Kárpát said his party was always ready to support appeals for legal remedy. He said there were no disagreements within the party over the matter, adding that Jobbik had been consistent in its view that “the network of [US financier George] Soros and intellectual well-poisoning” must not be allowed to gain ground in Hungary.

Z Kárpát stressed that Jobbik’s backing of an appeal to the top court did not mean that the party was standing up for “the Soros network” or Budapest’s Central European University, seen as impacted by the amendments. Any intelligent proposal will be backed by Jobbik, he insisted.

Budapest court submits FX retail loan query to Luxembourg

Budapest, March 3 (MTI) – The Budapest Municipal Appellate Court has submitted a query to the Court of Justice of the European Union on guidance for a case involving retail borrowers’ burden of responsibility for exchange rate risk, daily Magyar Idők said on Friday.

Balázs Lehoczki, who works for the Court of Justice’s press department, told the paper that the Hungarian court is seeking to determine whether a contract complies with EU law that makes exchange rate risk for an FX retail loan the sole responsibility of the borrower.

The main question is whether EU consumer protection laws allow such a contractual clause, he added.

The Budapest court has also asked the court in Luxembourg whether the issue can be reviewed at all, considering changes to Hungarian legislation on FX lending over the past years.

Hungarian lawmakers earlier ordered banks to give FX borrowers refunds and rebates for using exchange rate margins to calculate repayments and for making unilateral changes to contracts. They also required nearly all retail borrowers to convert their FX loans into forints. The measures resulted in a benefit of more than 1,000 billion forints (EUR 3.2bn) for borrowers and reduced FX retail lending stock, once the most popular loans in Hungary, to a negligible amount.

It takes the Court of Justice about one year to respond to such queries, Lehoczki told the paper.

Share of forex debt within total stat debt falls below 30 percent

Daily News Hungary economy

In the month of June 2016, the share of forex debt within the total volume of state debt was down by 5 percent year-on-year. Positive fiscal processes have also been recognized in the latest analysis by Moody’s Investors Service. The rating agency is expecting Hungary’s government debt-to-GDP ratio to decline further in coming years.

Moody’s states that the decline of this indicator will be attributable in the next two years to the Government’s fiscal policy, and the economic upturn, which is set to follow a transitory slow-down.

The Ministry for National Economy welcomes the fact that the share of forex debt within the total debt volume has gradually declined from 52 percent at the end of 2011, as it shows that the Government’s relevant measures have taken effect. One of these efforts has been the Government-initiated campaign for promoting government securities for retail investors which has achieved that 14 percent of the volume of government securities is now owned by households. And, as a result of a self-financing programme, 29 percent of state bonds are now being held by banks. This has reduced holdings of foreign investors, and non-residents now possess only 39 percent of government securities and 44 percent of the total volume of government debt. As a consequence, not only the country’s exposure to exchange rate fluctuations but its external vulnerability has also been reduced.

Recent years have proven that lower financial exposure is of significant value. Better risk indicators have led to lower yields on government securities, to lower interest payments and accordingly to cheaper debt financing. The amount thus saved can be allocated for other objectives, such as investment or development projects and higher wages.

Most borrowers arbitration cases related to settlement

Daily News Hungary

 

Budapest, May 27 (MTI) – Around 80 percent of cases Hungarians have brought before the Financial Arbitration Body for mediation are related to the settlement of borrowers relief, daily Magyar Idők said on Friday.

About 6,000 of the cases involve contested settlement amounts related to FX mortgages. Around 6,500 cases are related to FX car loans and 200 to forint loans.

Most of these cases were brought last year and have already been settled, Tünde Kardos-Nagy, the spokesperson for the body, told the paper.

Borrowers who believe their lenders failed to compensate them sufficiently may bring their cases to the board.

Lenders were earlier required to compensate borrowers for using exchange rate margins when calculating repayments on FX loans and for making unilateral changes to contracts.

More than half of FX loan contract disputes continued in court after settlement

Daily News Hungary

Budapest, March 1 (MTI) – A little more than half of Hungarian borrowers who sued their lenders over foreign-currency denominated loan contracts continued their cases even after they were compensated for unfair banking practices, daily Magyar Idők said on Tuesday.

About 12,000 cases involving foreign-currency loans were suspended after borrowers relief legislation approved in the summer of 2014 required lenders to refund their clients for using exchange rate margins when calculating repayments on foreign-currency loans and for making unilateral changes to contracts, the deputy head of the National Court Office told the paper. About 7,000 of these cases were restarted after banks settled with clients, and rulings have already been made on half of these, said Judit Gyarmathy.

New cases have also been launched, bringing the total number of foreign-currency loan contract disputes to 18,000, she added.

Economy minister: Brussels undermining Hungary’s debt reduction efforts

Budapest, December 17 (MTI) – Hungary’s efforts to reduce the public debt have been hindered by a protracted dispute with the European Union concerning the accounting of 600 billion forints (EUR 1.9bn) of EU payments, Economy Minister Mihaly Varga said on Thursday.

In the meantime, the government has had to fund projects using its own resources, Varga said in an interview to weekly Figyelo. It looks like Brussels is trying to undermine Hungary’s debt reduction efforts, he added.

The budget deficit is expected to be around 2.2 percent of GDP this year, below the target of 2.4 percent. But in the case of the public debt, “the situation is slightly different”, he added.

“For four years, we have always fulfilled the targets set by the law and will try to do the same this year,” Varga said.

The state is planning to renew in Chinese Renminbi part of the 5-5.5 billion euros FX debt expiring next year, Varga said. What is important is not the amount but the fact that new relations have been established that “could make the financing of state securities safer,” he added.

Also, Varga said real wages would have to rise by 2.5-4.5 percent to support domestic consumption.

In an interview published by Reuters on the same day, Varga said that he saw a good chance for MKB Bank and Budapest Bank to be privatised next year.

Talking about the euro-forint exchange rate Varga said forint levels around 308-310 per euro “would be better” and there is still a chance for the forint to firm in the remainder of the year.

Varga said there was a good chance this year for the state debt to decline from last year’s 76.2 percent of GDP. He said the government planned a further reduction in the budget deficit to 1.7 percent of GDP in 2017 and 1.6 percent in 2018, from less than 2.4 percent this year.

Varga said it was “very important” that Hungary should issue a renminbi-denominated bond next year under a deal signed with China in November. The upper limit of this issue could be 3 billion yuan and Hungary would decide later next year whether it would tap international markets in other currencies as well or refinance expiring debt from domestic issuance.

“We’ll see around the end of February how yields perform, whether debt agency AKK should continue to be active in the domestic market or go out again (to international markets)”, he told Reuters.

The minister noted that even with the privatisation of MKB and Budapest Bank the proportion of Hungarian ownership within the bank sector, currently close to 60 percent of the balance sheet total, should not decrease.

Photo: MTI

AKK plan shows EUR 20.25bn gross issuance next year

Daily News Hungary economy

Budapest, December 16 (MTI) – Hungary’s foreign debt manager AKK plans gross issuance of 6,389 billion forints (EUR 20.25bn) next year, a debt management outlook released on Wednesday shows.

AKK noted that 91 percent of the planned issuance would be in domestic currency. It also plans the issue of the equivalent of 1 billion euros of international bonds and a further 750,000 euros of domestic Residency Bonds and Premium Euro Hungarian Government Bonds.

Net issuance is set to reach 1,008 billion forints as net domestic issuance comes to 1,979 billion forints and the government repays net 971 billion forints of forex debt.

AKK reiterated its three main objectives in the report: to support the reduction of state debt, to increase the retail financing of the debt and to “significantly reduce” the share of FX debt.

AKK lowered its benchmark for the share of FX debt from 40 percent this year to “below 35 percent and declining” for 2016. It added that FX obligations after swaps should be 100 percent in euros, allowing for a 5 percent deviation.

Top court rejects complaints against FX loan conversion legislation

Daily News Hungary

Budapest, December 2 (MTI) – Hungary’s Constitutional Court rejected requests to declare legislation on the conversion of retail FX mortgages into forint unconstitutional, the court said on Wednesday.

The main aim of the obligatory conversion of the FX loans into forint ones was to defend debtors against eventual FX rate movements, the Court said. Also, the high ratio of FX or FX-denominated contracts within the lending stock constituted a risk to lenders and, thereby to the stability of the whole financial system.

The conversion was taken with a view on the general interest of society and came after significant changes in the environment that hurt the interests of many, therefore it intervened in contractual freedom in line with the constitution, the Court said, noting that such intervention does not necessarily go against the constitution.

Parliament passed legislation on the conversion of FX retail mortgages into forints in November 2014 which made the conversion, which happened at a fixed exchange rate, mandatory, with a few exceptions. Most of the remaining FX loans will also disappear under legislation on the conversion of FX retail car and personal loans passed in September.

Fitch: recovery of Hungarian banks underway

Daily News Hungary economy

London (MTI) – The operating environment for banks in Hungary has improved, due to positive developments in the economy and the government’s intention to facilitate a gradual normalisation of the banking business environment, Fitch Ratings said on Friday.

The ratings agency said in a peer review of Hungarian banks that the government’s commitment is reflected in the memorandum signed with the EBRD in February in which the government pledged to refrain from implementing new onerous banking legislation and to reduce the bank levy in 2016 and then further in 2017.

The Hungarian banking system is likely to be profitable in 2015 after an all-time high loss in 2014. However, prospects for the sector remain weak due to muted appetite for new credit in the economy, substantial legacy problem loans and thin margins in light of low interest rates, Fitch Ratings said.

Banks are unlikely to return to pre-crisis profitability because previous results were inflated by rapid growth and relaxed lending standards, and the regulatory environment has become much more restrictive, including increased capital requirements, Fitch Ratings said.

However, the inflow of new problem loans has reached its peak and asset quality should remain broadly stable in the near future due to muted credit growth and elimination of FX-induced credit risks in residential mortgages.

The sector’s liquidity in forints is strong and banks improved their self-financing capacity after the conversion of FX mortgages. Capitalisation remains a weakness at several large banks, but this pressure is mitigated by loan book deleveraging and capital injections from foreign parent banks, Fitch added.

Forint joins CLS multi-currency cash settlement system

Budapest, November 16 (MTI) – Hungary’s forint has become a part of the CLS system that settles payment instructions relating to underlying FX transactions, the company said on Monday.

The Hungarian unit is the first central and eastern European currency to be added to the CLS settlement system, and the 18th overall, they said.

“CLS … has started settling payment instructions in the Hungarian forint on behalf of its settlement members. While already one of the world’s top 25 most active currencies, we believe that the forint is a currency with significant growth potential,” CLS CEO David Puth said.

National Bank of Hungary governor Gyorgy Matolcsy welcomed the collaboration with CLS and noted that about 90 percent of trading in the Hungarian forint takes place internationally.

“The CLS model provides a proven and trusted model for safe and efficient settlement of FX transactions and reducing settlement risk will reinforce the stability of our financial system and benefit the wider economy,” he added.

The CLS system covers almost all of the global wholesale foreign exchange trading and now 18 currencies. During 2015 CLS has settled, on average, the equivalent of 4.8 trillion US dollars per day on behalf of its 64 settlement members and 18,000 indirect participants.

Photo: infoszfera.hu

Parliament passes forex car loan conversion bill

Budapest, September 22 (MTI) – Lawmakers on Tuesday passed legislation which orders the conversion of forex car loans and personal loans into forints.

The conversions will be carried out at foreign-currency rates recorded on Aug. 19. this year, but conditions of conversion will be brought level with forex mortage conversions earlier passed into law so that car loan holders get the same deal.

Lawmakers passed the bill with 115 in favour, 2 against and 61 abstentions.

The new law, submitted by Economy Minister Mihaly Varga, is expected to reduce repayments of Swiss franc-based loans by 31 forints on the Franc. Banks will be allowed to deduct 50 percent of the reduction from their company and sectoral taxes. As a part of an earlier agreement with banks, the legislation locks in rates for the conversion at the National Bank of Hungary’s euro and Swiss franc fixings on August 19, although the more favourable rates earlier used for FX mortgage conversions will still be applied to clients’ balances. The difference between the two rates will be shared in equal part by banks and the state. FX mortgages were earlier converted into forints by law.

Hungarians have more than 200,000 FX vehicle loan contracts totalling almost 305 billion forints (EUR 983m).

Banks fix exchange rate of FX car loans

Budapest, August 24 (MTI) – Banks will fix the exchange rate of foreign currency car loans on Monday, when the National Bank of Hungary (NBH) holds the first tender to provide them with the foreign currency necessary for converting the loans.

The conversion rate will be 287.20 forints to the Swiss franc, NBH managing director Marton Nagy told public news television channel M1 today.

Hungarians have more than 200,000 FX vehicle loan contracts totalling almost 300 billion forints.

Borrowers will be sent a letter on Dec. 15 detailing the amount of their debt, the new interest rate and the repayments.

The government and the Hungarian Banking Association signed an agreement on Wednesday on the forint conversion of FX car loans. The state and the banks will provide half and half of 31 billion as assistance to effectively lower conversion rates.

(HUF 100 = EUR 0.3234)

Police remove FX civil movement demonstrators in central Budapest

Budapest, July 23 (MTI) – Police removed 17 activists of a civil movement representing troubled forex mortgage holders who blocked a section of a street in central Budapest in a banned sit-down demonstration on Thursday morning, the police said on its website.

The movement originally asked permission from the police to stage a demonstration with about 100-400 participants to demand the suspension of foreclosures and compensation for unfair forex debt repayment conditions.

The police decided to ban the protest, arguing that it would block traffic.

The movement appealed to the municipal labour court which however upheld the police decision.

Photo: MTI

Varga says FX bond issuance possible, depending on market developments

Budapest, June 24 (MTI) – It is conceivable that Hungary may issue foreign currency bonds if developments on the market warrant such a move, though the government is focusing on financing mainly using forint-denominated securities, the economy minister said.

In an interview to Wednesday’s Napi Gazdasag daily, Mihaly Varga also said that it was possible the state would acquire more shares in the banking sector.

Talking about the budget, Varga said experts were continually monitoring budgetary trends and there was no sign the government would miss its deficit target. In fact, growth is expected to be more positive than initially forecast, and a decline in yields since means there is more fiscal room for manoeuvre, he added.

On the topic of loans in foreign currency, the minister said the central bank and the banking association were examining the possibility of forint conversions of the remaining, negligible amount of retail FX debt.

Photo: MTI

Socialists: FX loan conversion rate fair at 2010 rates

Daily News Hungary

Budapest, May 12 (MTI) – The government’s ill-conceived economic policies have weakened the forint, so the conversion of FX loans should have been carried out at 2010 rates, the opposition Socialists said on Tuesday.

Head of parliament’s budget committee and Socialist lawmaker Sandor Burany told public news channel M1 citing a recent survey by portfolio.hu that two-thirds of people interviewed said they were disappointed about the result of loan conversion.

Some 5-8 percent said their monthly instalments dropped by 20-30 percent, as earlier promised by the ruling Fidesz party.

Burany said this has revealed that it was the forint’s weakening, not the interest-rate policies applied by banks, that was the main reason for borrowers’ losses. He added that thanks to the Socialist governments’ successful crisis management efforts, the euro stood at around 260 against the forint and the Swiss franc around 180 in 2010. After five years of Fidesz government, the rates are currently 303 and over 290, respectively, which shows that Fidesz’s measures failed to resolve the main problem, he said.

The conditions of the government’s bailout package for forex borrowers included a conversion rate of 192 forints to the Swiss franc, a Fidesz spokesman told M1. If one is considering conversion at 2010 rates, it must be added that interbank forint interest rates stood at 5.47 percent then, compared with today’s 1.7 percent, Bence Tuzson said. He said most people were not disillusioned with the way accounts had been settled and to those who were, he would suggest turning to the Financial Mediation Board with a complaint.